Review feedback on #876:
- Codex (P2): the SessionStart "Where to write" brief said all auto-capture goes to
captureFolder, but captureFolder is only the PreCompact checkpoint folder. Narrowed
it — checkpoints go to captureFolder; decisions/tasks/notes follow
placementConventions (or topic folders when none are set), so proactive captures
aren't dumped into sessions/ alongside checkpoints.
- Claude review: replaced the em dash in the skills-source-guard echo string with a
hyphen so the instruction's console output stays ASCII (CLAUDE.md compatibility).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
- Focus question is now load-bearing: it drives an adaptive light folder-structure
suggestion and is stored. The placement step branches learn (existing project
with notes) vs suggest (new/empty project) instead of only learning.
- Seed schema notes via the write_note `metadata` param instead of content
frontmatter. The cloud write path silently coerces nested YAML to the string
'[object Object]', corrupting schema/settings (basic-memory-cloud#1000); the
metadata param round-trips correctly on both local and cloud.
- Surface placementConventions + captureFolder in the SessionStart brief so the
output style's "follow stored placement conventions" reflex has something to
follow — previously written by setup but never shown to Claude (dead config).
- Add a post-settings smoke test (run the hook's recall query, confirm routing)
and a restart prompt gated on outputStyle in the close.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Codex flagged (review 4397232451) that the hooks locate the CLI via
`command -v basic-memory || command -v bm`, but our own README recommends
connecting the MCP server as `claude mcp add basic-memory -- uvx basic-memory mcp`
— an ephemeral uv run that leaves NO binary on PATH. In that (recommended) setup
both hooks exited before doing anything, so the bridge silently did nothing even
though the MCP server worked.
Both hooks now resolve the CLI invocation as: prefer a `basic-memory`/`bm` binary
(fast), else fall back to `uvx basic-memory`, else `uv tool run basic-memory`, else
silent no-op. The launcher may be multi-token, so the embedded Python splits it with
shlex and prepends it to each command list. The uv cache is already warm from
running the MCP server, so the fallback is cheap.
Verified: with no binary on PATH but uvx present, SessionStart now produces a brief
(previously a silent no-op). Updated the README requirement to note uvx-only works.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Resolves the in-scope findings from the github-actions review (its prepared commit
1283a46 couldn't push — 403) and the Codex P2 (review 4397168884):
- pre-compact.sh: route a UUID primaryProject via --project-id, not --project.
This mirrors session-start.sh; without it a UUID-configured project gets correct
session briefs but SILENT checkpoint failures at every compaction. The substantive
correctness fix. Verified end-to-end (checkpoint now lands in a UUID-keyed project).
- skills/share/SKILL.md: same UUID routing for /basic-memory:share team targets —
pass external_id UUIDs as project_id, qualified names as project. (Codex P2.)
- skills/status/SKILL.md: read outputStyle from the ROOT settings object, not the
basicMemory block — otherwise /basic-memory:status reports capture reflexes as off
for a correctly-configured user.
- docs/getting-started.md: move outputStyle out of the basicMemory block to root in
the team example (matches settings.example.json; it's a top-level Claude Code key).
- session-start.sh: split the >100-char project-routing line.
Out of scope here: the hermes/__init__.py getattr-rationale comments the bot
prepared live in the #859 consolidation code (not in this PR's diff) — flagged for
that PR. Plugin validates; hooks smoke-tested.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
1. SessionStart worker pool was sized 8 but submits up to 9 searches (3 primary
+ MAX_SHARED=6 shared) — the 9th queued behind a possibly-10s call and could
push the hook past Claude Code's 20s SessionStart timeout before the brief
printed. Size the pool to 3 + MAX_SHARED so nothing queues. (Introduced in
Phase 4 when the third primary query was added.)
2. captureChattyness was dead config — written by setup but read by no hook, and
its "heavy" level advertised "checkpoint without compaction," which no hook
implements. The real proactivity knob is `outputStyle`. Removed
captureChattyness entirely and folded the "how active should I be?" question
into the output-style step (the single, actually-wired toggle); the always-on
hooks run regardless. Updated setup skill, settings.example.json, and DESIGN.
Both flagged by Codex (review 4395911984); same class as the recallTimeframe
dead-config fix from the earlier self-review. Plugin validates; hook smoke-tested.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Resolves the 8 self-review findings on PR #865:
session-start.sh:
- Wire recallTimeframe into a new "Recent sessions" query (--after_date) — it was
parsed but unused after the Phase 4 rewrite. The brief now surfaces recent
session checkpoints (the resume cursor), which is the one query the recency
window legitimately applies to. (#1)
- Guard secondaryProjects/teamProjects JSON types — a string value was iterated
character-by-character into bogus per-char queries. (#3)
- A configured-but-unreachable/misnamed primaryProject now emits a one-line
"couldn't read" signal instead of a silent blank brief. (#7)
pre-compact.sh:
- Filter transcript turns by the `isMeta` and `toolUseResult` flags instead of a
`text.startswith("<")` heuristic. This stops dropping legitimate user messages
that start with "<" (#4) and stops capturing tool-result/meta frames as human
turns (#8) — verified against a real transcript (25 human turns cleanly
separated from 8 meta + 288 tool-result frames).
- Title now uses second precision so rapid same-minute compactions don't collide
and silently drop/overwrite a checkpoint; removed the unused stamp/slug. (#2)
- Empty-checkpoint guard now requires at least one real user turn, not just any
turn, so an assistant-only transcript can't produce a dangling-title note. (#5)
validate_skills.py:
- parse_frontmatter now skips indented lines, capturing only top-level keys, so a
schema note's nested schema:/settings: children can't overwrite a top-level
type/entity via last-write-wins. Documented its single-line-only limitation. (#6)
All verified end-to-end; `just package-check-claude-code` and
`package-check-skills` pass; ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Implements DESIGN.md Phase 4, grounded in a real two-workspace BM Cloud account.
Recall reads across the team:
- hooks/session-start.sh rewritten to read the primary project (active tasks +
open decisions) AND each configured shared/team project (open decisions) in
parallel via ThreadPoolExecutor. Routes by workspace-qualified name or
external_id UUID (project names collide across workspaces, so bare names won't
route); per-call timeout, capped at 6 shared projects, graceful on any failure.
Adds a "From shared projects (read-only)" section + the share-vs-capture note.
Verified against the real my-team-2 workspace (OAuth routing) and local fixtures.
Deliberate team writes:
- skills/share/SKILL.md → /basic-memory:share <note>: copies a note from the
primary project into a configured teamProjects target's promoteFolder, with
shared_from attribution and a confirmation step. Preserves the note's type so
shared decisions stay findable in the team's structured recall. Pulled forward
from future-work since team usage needs a safe write path.
Safe by default: capture (PreCompact checkpoints, /remember) NEVER writes to a
shared project. The proposed teamProjects.autoWrite flag is deliberately not
shipped — documented as future rather than ship an unenforced flag.
Config: secondaryProjects (read sources) + teamProjects (share targets with
promoteFolder), both requiring qualified names/UUIDs. setup interview step 3 now
configures them via list_workspaces; status reports team read-sources + share
targets; settings.example.json documents the shape. REQUIRED_SKILLS adds share.
Discovery verified: Skills (4): remember, setup, share, status. Passes
`just package-check-claude-code` incl. `claude plugin validate . --strict`.
Updated README (Teams section), CHANGELOG, and DESIGN §6 + Phase 4 status.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Adds the bootstrap interview from DESIGN.md Phase 3 as a prose skill, plus the
first-run nudge that points users to it.
- skills/setup/SKILL.md → /basic-memory:setup: an adaptive ~2-min interview that
maps the Claude Code project to a Basic Memory project (pick existing or create),
seeds the session/decision/task schemas into it, optionally learns the project's
placement conventions (list_directory + sampling, stored in placementConventions),
writes the basicMemory settings block, and enables the capture output style.
- hooks/session-start.sh: nudges toward /basic-memory:setup on first run (when no
basicMemory config block exists). The nudge now survives a failed/empty task
query, so a brand-new user with no project yet still sees it; it stops once setup
writes the config (config presence is the sentinel — no separate file).
- validate_claude_plugin.py: REQUIRED_SKILLS now includes setup.
Corrects the Phase 1 schema-seeding finding: writing a schema file's content via
write_note (CLI or MCP) indexes it as type: schema AND resolves via schema_validate
— the earlier "must use note_type/metadata" conclusion was confounded by the enum
YAML bug (since fixed). Verified end-to-end: all three schemas seed, index, and
resolve (entity=Session/Decision/Task); nudge verified across all config states;
discovery shows Skills (3): setup, remember, status.
Updated README, CHANGELOG, and DESIGN Phase 3 status. Passes
`just package-check-claude-code` incl. `claude plugin validate . --strict`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Reframes the Claude Code plugin as the bridge between Claude's working
memory and Basic Memory's durable graph, per plugins/claude-code/DESIGN.md.
This is the minimal-first vertical slice with a clean break from v0.3.x.
Added:
- hooks/session-start.sh — SessionStart brief: one structured `type: task`
query against the configured (or default) project + always-on recall
prompt. Plain stdout, silent if BM is absent.
- hooks/pre-compact.sh — PreCompact checkpoint: writes a `type: session`
note before compaction (extractive). Only writes when primaryProject is
set, so it never touches an un-opted-in graph.
- output-styles/basic-memory.md — capture reflexes (search-first, typed
decision notes, cite permalinks); keep-coding-instructions: true.
- schemas/{session,decision,task}.md — picoschema seeds (validation: warn)
so plugin-written notes are findable via metadata_filters. task mirrors
the memory-tasks skill.
- settings.example.json — copyable config with sensible defaults.
Removed (clean break):
- the six bundled skills, the basic-memory-manager agent, the
PreToolUse/PostToolUse write_note hooks, the basic-memory config-note
convention, and PLUGIN.md. Equivalent workflows live in top-level skills/.
Other:
- Rewrote scripts/validate_claude_plugin.py for the new layout (hooks +
output-style + schemas; agent dropped; skills optional). Passes
`just package-check-claude-code` incl. `claude plugin validate --strict`.
- Rewrote README around the bridge story; updated CHANGELOG, marketplace
descriptions, and the AGENTS.md package-check note.
- Hooks tested end-to-end against throwaway projects (brief surfaces tasks;
checkpoint writes a queryable session note; both degrade silently).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Signed-off-by: phernandez <paul@basicmachines.co>
Paul Hernandez